Monday, August 3, 2009

The Indominitable Cheesesteak

I have become a fan of the cheesesteak. I did not grow up in the Philadelphia area, but once discovered, they are really good eats. Here in Maryland, there was a place nearby that had authentic cheesesteaks, going so far as bringing in Amoroso rolls from Philadelphia. My sister-in-law lives in Wilmington, Delaware and that is close enough to Philly to be able to find really good cheesesteaks from a variety of places. On several visits to Philadelphia, I have been fortunate enough to have the real things from Pat's, Geno's, and, until it closed in Reading Terminal Market, Rick's. Anna van Schurman very kindly informed me that Rick's can still be had in the greater Philadelphia area. They've opened a new outpost, eight months after leaving the Market.

Like last week's post about gyros, there is absolutely no reason to make your own cheesesteaks. But if you must here's a recipe (following the Pat's formula).
  1. Start with good beef. Pat’s uses sliced rib-eye. Jim’s uses USDA choice top round western steer beef.
  2. Shave the beef very thin so it cooks quickly and remains tender.
  3. Use a fresh high quality Italian roll - Amoroso’s is a favorite.
  4. Decide if you want your steak with or without fried onions.
  5. Decide if you want a steak or a cheesesteak. If you elect a cheesesteak you need to decide on American cheese, provolone or the Philly favorite "cheez whiz."
  6. Any add-ons? Mushrooms, peppers, pizza sauce, tomatoes? You decide. It’s your sandwich.
  7. Start to cook. Sauté the onions, peppers and mushrooms until soft.
  8. Fry your steak until brown but not crispy or burned. You can mix in the fried vegetables now or add them at the end.
  9. If you elect American cheese or provolone place the cheese on the meat until slightly melted. If you choose Cheez Whiz just smear it on the roll.
  10. Place the roll over the meat/cheese/vegetables and scoop it into the sandwich.
  11. Garnish your sandwich with pizza sauce, hot or sweet peppers or pickles as you choose.
  12. Enjoy your Philadelphia cheesesteak.
Tips:
  1. Using the best beef available is the key.
  2. Don't overcook the ingredients.
  3. If you don't cook, go to Pat's, Geno's or Jim's. Which one is best? It's a regular Philadelphia debate.

4 comments:

Philly Girl said...

Pat's, Genos, and Ricks were all passed over as best steaks in town in a 2002 graduation project that took 4 high school seniors, mentored by Phila Inquirer food critic Craig LaBan, all over the city, and into the surround 'burbs testing steaks. They determined the best steaks were found at John's Roast Pork (Snyder Avenue near Columbus Blvd, weekdays only to 2:30 pm). Best of the "big name" eateries was Tony Luke's on Oregon Avenue in the shadow of I-95 (easy ride for Brave Astronaut's sister-in-law.)

As for Amoroso (overgrown hotdog roll), Philly Girl prefers crusty bread for her steaks and hoagies. Harder to find in Phila and surrounding area, but prevalent "down the Shore."

Brave Astronaut said...

Philly - Fair enough. Then again, I grew up on Steak-Ums. I have been successfully converted.

Danielle said...

Food Critics?? Aren't they just people with tastebuds like everybody else?! Who says their opinion of food is superior to anyone else's? They may even be biased in their critiques, especially when it comes to friends and/or business relationships. I have noticed this with the above mentioned food critic in particular. I say...be your own food critic! Taste food for yourself...and if YOU like it...EAT IT!

Brave Astronaut said...

Danielle - A fine philosophy to live by.